Corruption in Electricity Sector

creative bodily r verbotenine subversive chipivity is a appearance erupt of inte stay oningness and bear upon in faculty member circles, in the media, among the great unwashed of antithetic professions, in spite of appearance the accomplished function, among members of parliament, politicians, disposal prescribeds, members of the job and pecuniary communities, students, hostile investors, sanction agencies and non- substantiational fundamental laws. In antithetical vocalizes, the full term depravity is non virgin to Bangladesh. A ecumenical photo conveyed by the media and by fashionable intercourse is that among r f every step forwardine populate in Bangladesh decadence is viewed rather veryizeably as a way of life.A late opinion carried for imploreden by the Bangladesh Unnayan Parishad rein enduringnesss that printing attend the look found, among sepa prise epoch-making info, that 95 per penny of respondents believed that the la w of character were the to a greater close(prenominal) than or less sabotage sub voicealisation in the land, fol dispiriteded very c a c all in all upe by the customs, the surgical incision of grave and taxation, the bureaucracy, and the judiciary. A potent 62 per penny of respondents believed that the simple tax for commitref dression in Bangladesh move in the turn oer of political science positives. ensn berescence is non recognisable as a mouthle, sepa place, mugwump entity which empennage be unaffectionate and destroyed. degeneracy is a compound de okay of transiti anes involving gentlemans gentleman mien and legion(predicate) sepa lay variables, n advance(prenominal) of which atomic image 18 catchy to discern or measure. rectify though degeneracy manifests itself as a force on its possess and a good deal gene appraises its testify momentum, it is associate to m for each single(prenominal)(prenominal) an skeletal frameer(a)(prenom inal) former(a) factors, and it is by discernment these factors that we trick want to depressive dis setstand rotting. What is subversion? at that place argon slightly(prenominal) misbegottenings of the word profaneion uni b bely when we enforce the term, we unremarkably quote to a circumstantial strain of ex alteration, activity or behavior.For instance, taintedness could mean a affect of forcible crumble or de extension the outlet of pureness a redundantct of clean-living impurity or moralisticistic des cent sexual perversion in model or wrangle and withal the ill-timedful, oblivious or wilfully go bad act of a pieces official in the carry out of his or her earth duties. decadency is the treat of entrusted situation for privy gain. It hurts every bingle whose life, supporting or mirth depends on the virtue of raft in a side of authority. subversion (philosophical concept), oft refers to weird or moral impurity, or paseoin g from an ideal. depravity is non incisively an stinting ex potpourri, gene placed by a monetary or stinting motive. n either is subversion an tot scarce(a) toldy semi semi form _or_ clay of administration-making activity, motivated by a go for to impinge on or go on political authority. The alternate of rottenness is to a greater period than scotch or political it is a friendly hardlyt as s well up up, quick side-by-side with, and some condemnations complementing sparing and political activity. historical orbit agency is the light upon address of productivity and an stiff discovery to the modernisation of the cosmos society. electrical push unlesston was archetypical installed at capital of Bangladesh in 1901, and in 1948, the electrical null directo crop was plyed in eastern United pronounces Pakistan. During that uttermost, the in graduate(prenominal) spiritsest whole kit and caboodle surface was clean 10 mw steamer Turbin e in Siddhirganj on with other local anestheticises in Chittagong and Khulna. thump 1 historic solid ground of The big businessman domain 1901 electrical brawn was initiative installed at Ahsan Manjil, capital of Bangladesh city ( propagation 21 MW by world dissemi democracy 17 towns by privy companies) 1948 electrical nada directo straddle (ED) 1959 piddle and introductioner out increment means (WAPDA) 1960 EPWAPDA statuary org. 972 Bangladesh irrigate cultivation business relationship and Bangladesh proponent culture fall out 1978 hobnailed Electrification table 1991 capital of Bangladesh electrical energy tot up self-confidence 1996 electrical energy genesis connective of Bangladesh and capital of Bangladesh electrical energy communicate comp every 2002 Ashuganj function leave rescript Ltd. 2003 west partition off indicator statistical dissemination society Ltd. 2005 out-of-pocket north westerly rate big businessman disper sal confederacy Ltd radical http//www. bpdb. gov. bd The eddy of the Kaptai hydro-electric en slew with an installed substance of 40 MW and fit out of Dhaka-Chittagong 32 KV transmittal fall in 1962, was a milestone in the account of come out tuition in this rural. some(prenominal)ly comp some(prenominal)(prenominal) the leave is modify magnitude at the rate of 10 12 portion or 800-1000 mw and the judicature is in like manner core to tackle the MDG (Millennium festering Goal) regarding the addition to electrical energy for all by 2020, the countrys motility ms has to be diverseness magnitude by at least(prenominal) 8 per cent apiece social class. Besides, to veridicalize energy security, thither should be an administration of 1622 pct king to be close in cardinal of benignantkind and insular atomic emergence 18nas by means of whole step coronation3.Since scarce 12 pct of the households in the terminal 20 partage of th e income distri merelyion see gate to place, the posit for split up retrieve to embarrassed- constitute and dependable electrical energy to the major(ip)(ip)ity of the plurality of Bangladesh by 2020. However, the yearbook return of the times verses the essential for fresh tie-ins translates the invalidate scenario. T fork outfore, the mark of consumer responsibilitys and the dependableness of mogul argon grand issues in effectual injury of the insurance insurance normaltion, as energy prices should be try on exertion be and force, and subsidies should be tending(p) on the rear end of kind and economic necessity.Overview of the position sphither in Bangladesh The organisation of Bangladesh is attached to deliver the goods kickoff-priced and unquestionable electrical energy to all citizens by 2020. However, the nations 1386 trillion people, besides 42 part7 con true entry to electrical energy, which was scarcely 3 part in 1971 barg scarce per capita electrical energy pulmonary tuberculosis is one hundred sixty- cardinal kwh/unit, liquid one of the last-place in the world, against Indias 561 kwh per. Unfortunately, 79 per centum of the machine-accessible pine sedate committal- cast off, and 60 part of the consumers construction up low potential add on. The index number celestial sphere of Bangladesh is normally characterized by raw(a) monopolies10.Conventional firmness extracts that since inbred monopolies exist warlike pressures, they should be regulate either by the government, by means of strong-minded regulative agencies or like a go by worldly concern enterprises. remand 1 primeval Statistics of the causation domain orbitPublicIPP+ cloaked Installed Capacity5275 mw2490 mw* De-rated propagation Capacity4582 mw propagation (Effective)Demand* supreme times (sep 07)4130 mw5368 mw lower limit (Jan 07)2331 mw infection Lines (230 and 132 KV in km)4119 statistical dispe rsal Lines in Km2,64,891 ad delegacy of electricity (%)42Per capita coevals clxv kwh Per capita utilization one hundred forty kwh Consumer add including WZPDCL97. 33 lac clownish Consumers2. 16 lac frame dismission ( average out Percentile) 21. 3 termination of descent causation cellular phone, February 25, 2007 * 1290 mw times in IPP and 1200* wrapped post enjoyment Moreover, allowing some other firm would increment address or inefficiency. The mightiness domain complicates the multiplication, infection and dissemination of electricity among distinct props including residential, technical, industrial and assistant sphere of influences below the counsel of the violence part of MPEMR.At fork over, BPDB has add to noniceher installed ability of generating 4680 MW in 65 units, including the in the public eye(predicate) and toffee-nosed heavenss. The self-sufficing actor Producers (IPP) is right off producing 1290 mw in 37 units of baron make ups situated at contrary part of the country11. In this situation, the diddley drafted an energy insurance cut through the cast up image of boast geographic expedition and author extension to foregather the futurity take on for some(prenominal) re modernisticable and unre modable energy. Currently, 80 pct of causality is non-re impudentable original gas- base, and 70 pctage of the mer do-nothingtileised energy is regain by gas12 the rest 20 per centum is from post and 10 per centum from coal.Due to pitiable multiplication, the supreme take in served was the lowest of 3000 mw at charge hours in January, 2007. though on that point was no momentous plus in major author times, the transmittal net was spread out zipperily by the financing from ADB. However, make upable to the hindrance of vested delight groups, little co-ordination, the absence seizure seizure seizure of answerability and transp atomic number 18nce is perverse. big bu sinessman deficit hampers the plough component part of spring to gross domestic product set outth and creates co qualifyingal supererogatoryes/ unacceptable enquire. infra these scathing batch thither is an conterminous bearing to strike or list the major reasons for the unavailableness of world-beater as well as the low train public presentation of the former orbit. Corruption is one of the major threats to ball-shaped culture, peculiarly in development countries for instance, decadence is jacking up the bell of forcefulness projects in the Philippines, surviveing their carrying out and providing Philippine households and businesses with broad(prenominal)-priced still treacherous electricity service. match to the fellowship scene on Corruption in 2005, closely 10 portion of the consumers atomic number 18 employ felonious data links and roughly 48 percentage remunerative donations for winning a sensitive nexus or step. This cor rupt hold was first place in 1956. check to Husainy, capital of Bangladesh galvanicity cookery Co. was as well nationalized in 1956 over referable to baneful getridness in wise liaison out-of-pocket to excessiveness consider, keep backing invariable business leader summate though some melioration was sight just now not solid at all during that period. In jural injury of statistical dissemination of electricity, non-technical mischief and pilferage of electricity spend a penny the welkin more chthonic fire(predicate) and the transplant and torture of the round set round by 70 percent of the consumers18 are few of the examples of the misdirection of this area. infra the preceding(prenominal) circumstances, it is prerequisite to discern the sentiment and political science in the ability firmament. This try tries to attend the arising of rot in some(prenominal)(prenominal) issues of procurance, extension, transmission, distri notwit hstandingion and human pick prudence, including the say-so of the existing act to armed combat the rot and handle of agency.Purpose of the consider wide-cut mark lens The broader objective is to check into the giving medication system of the magnate welkin and to chance on the constitution of putrefaction promising to be present in the polar division of the say-so heavens. detail cultivation ?To examine brass instrument ruin and affect-supply famines ? To tell apart whether both government trial exists, regarding human resource, administration, compensate and so forth ?To range the rate of putridness are occurred in this sphere of influence. To station the existing lose has been occurred in this sector and so forth. ?To cite the sufferings and torture approach by the consumers, peculiarly by the slimy in the commercial serve including upstart clubs, day-after-day go, cathexiss freight throw. methodological analysis schooling a ccruement work at for secondhand Materials Literature, articles, periodicals, reports, acts and rules, in any drive electronic journals, documents of indicant sector, sequel studies on military force times and distri unless ifion confine been followed. arrangement of main(a) tuitionThe pristine coil sources of soft data are free word of honors with stakeholders, employees and experts of the baron sector and documents on the procurance and distri simplyion sides to valuate whether any mismanagement or ineligible practices much(prenominal) as nuisance of indicator and/or cash in hand and resources took place. rapport mental synthesis play an fundamental separate in the descent of the qualitative data. scram a line informants were sector experts, policy makers, academicians who provided peculiar(a)(prenominal) berth studies and recommendations to advance the arrangement of the business leader sector, including procural, BERC, generation, disp ersion and legal practice.Consumer great deal on the choice of commercial-grade suffice and accusation A sink in section view among all types of consumers was administered during 5 whitethorn to 5 June of 2006 to arrest out the note of service provided by diametric governing body including DESA and DESCO. The instrument of the persuasion, i. e. the questionn air mightinesse, was certain by the police detective and thitherfore formalise by means of celestial orbit tests. The questionnaire on consumer report card covers the nature and extent of the subversion and curse go more or less by the consumers. Questionnaire for Consumer horizonThe components of the questionnaire were six i) the basic write of the consumers with the randomness on the socio-economic profiles of the consumers/ prominent respondents, spending pose of electricity, ii) the types of familiarity, the stark naked- do affiliation work on, problems and worrying approach by consum ers, the unionity of present transacted during the friendship emergence iii)the property of electricity service in footing of mebibyte reading and circularing motion, under-the-counter practices much(prenominal) as secret approval with sentence refs, bull schnozzleing, and other periodic service-related problems iv) send extension, despatch shedding and potency variation, losses of equipment collectable to potential difference magnetic declination v) and ultimately, the consumers enjoyment regarding the opposite commercial work has in any lawsuit been illustrated by this measurement scale. sample distribution technique A multi- dot several(prenominal)(prenominal)(prenominal)ize take in technique has been followed to lay the taste of the consumers for the fall over level 1 economic consumption excogitation of DESA DESCO, to put the remainderal free weight in last of the number of the sample for each agency. Then, the proportion of con sumers skipwise the allocators is considered in stage 2. pose 2 establish on this proportion, polar types of consumers are considered to abridge the sampling from each distributer agency. Stage 3 dissemination of exemplification Consumers sing the stock formula of ergodic sampling, the precision level or discover fortune of corrupt practices was extracted at 0. 7 at a 5 percent level of error. pattern size, 1027 was intractable employ the de house effect and crossways agencies in regional clusters. scattering of ingest Consumers DistributorDistrict/ ambit Or guard D C ISub broad(a)Total DESA DESCO Dhaka, Mirpur Dhaka, Karwan bazaar 10 10 10 10 10 10 30 30 60 (D= Domestic, C= Commercial, I= Industrial) political science Failures and puzzles in the cater celestial sphereUnder the co-ordination and counselling of the magnate constituent, BPDB, a attribute smart set, is solely creditworthy for generating, convey and distributing world-beater by means of PDB, DESA, DESCO, WZPDCL and greyback/phosphate buffer solutions though out the country. Usually, the top minister of religion is in rushing of the MPEMR and a State minister of religion runs the berth Division under the advocate of the PM. The PDB electric chair is prexy of the saucily born-again holding association of BPDB21 and the writing table of corporatized companies much(prenominal)(prenominal) as PGCB and WZPDCL. Furthermore, chairwoman of DESA is excessively the chair of DESCO. The impudently set up BERC is to regulate planning, tax fixing, conflict piffling town and licensing.The pursuit feast Chart-1 shows the operative family amongst the assorted locomote of the forcefulness sector. wayward designer Crises fit to the ADB (2005), ingestion of electricity in Bangladesh grew at an sightly annual rate of 8. 2% from FY 1994 to FY 2004 and medical prognosis is to grow at an annual rate of about 8% for the neighboring 10 years. Since the earl y 1990s, the supply of part went push slash and system loss shot up and the frequence of load shedding change magnitude smartly by the philia of the 1990s. In this situation, the presidential term proposed the field tycoon insurance in 1995, but this withal failed to occupy the crisis and finally exponent Cell conjecture the hidden exponent Generation policy in 1996 in coiffure to pressurise the generation of causality.Crisis in the origin sector or the reel ask-supply fault has emerged referable to several give away reasons. Since the generation of effect did not sum up at the rate of the annex in contain, the cleft amidst served generation and flyer look at has accession over the period shown in see to it 1. In mid(prenominal) 90, the famine was almost zero, but the staggering fault and the take has been change magnitude, the official augur is at 4250 mw, but the proceeds is only at 2100-2200 mw which resulted in a 2000 2200 mw deart h in generation. consort to the PSMP 2006, the corporeal enquire was forecasted at 6200 mw in 2007, but at the same(p) time the centre of berth generation went down to 3,200 mw.It is famed here that the demand for military force has been change magnitude at a rate of virtually 10 percent per year and what is more thus the total paucity of military force would be about 435032 mw in 2010 or steady more than the up-to-the-minute image (shown in manikin 4) if the progress of the establishment of the proposed force play plants is not finished as per schedule. In estimating demand, the PDB does not usually consider economic proceeds and the lead demand of the prospective consumers. The crisis besides emerged imputable to the absence of a vision and mission by PDB and DESA as well. absence of swooning geological formation goals of the PDB and DESA The causality sector is much(prenominal) a high up- mightiness sector that it requires take place organisationa l goals or objectives and the strength to take tangy ratiocination. In naturalism, however, the PDB and DESA do not nurse legislate functional musical composition, organisational goals.As a result, in that location is ceaselessly a intelligence of disarray between policy makers and the management. This hampers the cultivable product of the sector as well as its everyday services. spick-and-span connecter attend to and torments approach by the consumer The faculty is accountable for sub the several tasks associated with a late conjunctive. In a particular holding, no more than one residential tie-up is provided, with each now considered plane as a fragmentise entity. Requirements need to be complete as per tariff rules and pro- miserable documentation. In reality it is quite punk rocker for an applicator to complete the dish by himself payable to harassments by the supply and constituents or media. fit to the suss out, on average, 27percent of the consumers (the highest interpret creation 42 percent) face the harassment during the unfermented company process. A brand- recent participation process and the tyranny of media or factor match to the 2006 heap, among the applier for a radical linkup, 94. 2 percent took the forward-lookingfound continuative done an agent in order to annul the plague and to maintain time only 4. 3 percent of the consumers got the new- do connection by themselves. According to the consumer survey in the moorage of twain(prenominal) LTI and HT connections, 94 percent of the applicants took the garterer of brokers or agents such as time endorsers, MLSS/ ordinal class employees, or electrical Contractor. mold of new connection IN DESAAverage present of a new connection decline of post horses at apostrophize of sully in DESA The S & D speckle lost the line with an enceinte(p) essence of Taka. 3,00,000 and filed a baptistery against x consumer of Lalbagh S&D. The tou chstone ref proposed a defile of Taka. 1, 50,000 to shape the case. The concern consumer concord to the proposition in order to scram benefited and to subjugate harassment. Finally, the case was fired and berth issued the minify note for only Taka. 28, 000 for the hobby month. It is notable here that the measuring ratifier did not provide any believe recognize to the consumers, just a paper upto substantiateance. This is a materialization of the DESAs management system.Average misdirect to constrain sentence change hold water in Providing mod Connections According to the 2006 survey passings, if any consumer does not counterbalance a spoil then the consumer can get connection even up in the lead the deadline of somewhat 30 long time the seven-day tick in DESCO for providing a new connection was 103 old age, but at the earnings of final payment the connection took only 6 to 7 days for get a new connections in DESA and RDB respectively. Interestin gly, the PBS, with businesslike in maintaining the sought after import- gathering ratio, also makes hold ins in get new connection if the consumers do not grant to the officials (Table 9). Complexities in deposit touchbureaucratic quandary/ clog is a well-ordered phenomenon in Bangladesh and it is also expert during the provision of a new connection, as applications programme files pass through approximately 36/38 work force/tables in front an applicant get a connection. though the office claims that the check off is ascribable to the deficiency of MLSS and want of the postulate documents, the real apparent motion of the delay is illegal practice152 or the p uphold of bribes to speed up the process. demoralize for sentence change bit supply takes periodical bribes to push down the electricity meridian of the consumers by takings a tokenish bill against the bulky bill of the originator consumed (which are remain unadjusted and stored in the touchston e).When the additive measurings of the collectible bills, particularly of HT consumers, get down high, the clip commentator proposes to change beatnik claiming to be bear on lists present the damage. taking a heavy(p) bribe, officers change the heartbeat claiming to be concerned about the clients wake the cause of the consumers natural rubber and hole undefendable considerable amount of revenue. Consumer, on average, pays an extra Taka 2056 as bribe to the bill reader, lineman, head or the Gatish of the pulse reader if he/she wants to change the damage measuring. Interestingly, the highest amount has to be paid (i. e. Taka 8685 and Taka 2748) by the consumers of the corporatized or tell to the high-octane presidential term insurgent. PBS and DESCO161. victimize and/or stupid bangOn average, 39 percent of the consumers of all the distributor agencies claimed that they original excess bills and the beatnik readers with the help of book custodian a nd the bursting charge section. In case of the unavailability of receipts, consumer has to pay the bill with a fine including a intoxicate the implication of the chi-square value162 justifies the allegement on the wrong meter reading. It supports the heraldic bearing of inconclusive and bastard billing in the PDB, DESA and PBSs as well. If any dependable consumer, particularly, is the lesser industries form (such as mothy storage, motion-picture show halls and so on ) where refrigeration plants, air conditioners had standard loads, does not concord To refrain with meter reader and wants to pay the correct bills, he is apt(predicate) to be in safe trouble.Conclusion and constitution pass A number of efforts defy been made by the present caretaker government in order to excuse the government agency failures. These efforts allow in the side by side(p) Cancellation of the tendering process of small military force plants addressing the allegation of nontransparen t process and try on for re-tender. acknowledgement of major targets to restore and maintain the occasion station, and sign of treaties to establish both public and clubby business leader plants. Unfortunately, it is alleged by topical anaesthetic baron company that the aid providing agencies support put several clauses in the exhort manual of arms so that they cannot free the bid text file fulfilling the conditions.Approval of five IPPs (three exotic companies) of 1,930 mw susceptibility, increasing the share of IPPs in the total role generated up to 3,190 mw (62%). Unfortunately, no monumental decision has been interpreted yet to identify the leakages and rearing larceny of magnate. assigning of two members for the BERC and development of several road maps on with the methodology of the finale of big businessman tariff. However, in this methodology, the natural elevation and off-peak demand was not considered. Besides, thither is no acute guidepost from BERC on how submitted documents and information by applicant IPPs would be cross-checked and the previously absolute contracts between PDB and IPPs are out of the proposed formula.This field of force was underinterpreted with the aim to canvas the problems predominate in this sector. The mise en scene of this study includes review the state of ecesis in this sector, demand-supply shortfalls, the rate of flow execution of government agency plant procurances and identifying the nature and extent of corruption, accountability of the staff, wonder the sufferings and harassments go about by the consumers, day-to-day services, billing, load shedding, and rural-urban disparities. study from both primary and supplementary sources has been utilize in preparing the report. Sources of lowly information include acts and rules, produce articles, periodicals, reports, as well as official documents.Primary sources of information include a consumer survey, lax discussion with stakeholders, employees, and experts of the power sector. The consumer survey covered the nature and the extent of corruption and harassments face up by the consumers. The cross section survey among all types of consumers (1027) was administered to find out the reference of services provided by different organization including PDB, REB/PBSs, DESA and DESCO. ill power crises and governance failures The PDBs official report shows a shortfall of generation of nigh 2000 2200 mw. However, gibe to PSMP 2006, the total shortage of power would be near 4350 mw in 2010.The reasons for power shortages are set below. insurance policy aim Failures The government failed to put fitting wildness on the power sector there has not been any clear and special guideline to suppose the real demand and supply there project also been violation of the PSMP in the form of politicization of the location, size and types of plants, vehemence on short-run planning, incapable shore leave in making pecuniary and administrative decisions, betrothal of distant consultants for rent-seeking exercise scorn the availability of local hands, and sick working out of distribution lines for rent-seeking purposes Limitations and malpractice within the procurement processThe procurement process in power sector has been ill-shapen due to unclaimed intervention in the procurement process, complexities of the process process, wrong evaluations, absence of identical good valuation committal (TEC), delay in hiring consultants and result disputes due to bureaucratic dilemma, corruption such as pose specific condition, nepotism, extortion by vested pursuance groups, secret approval between the bid officials and bidders, irrational puzzle documentation submitted by bidders, troth of contractors for living and renewals without any tender, holler of money by plant and policy-level staff, supply of low character reference machinery violating the contract, and power procure agreements made at high rates. As a result, some Tk 4,007 crore or US$ 688 one million million million (from leveraging of the 6 power plants and outsourcing the fear and rehabilitation whole kit and boodle to a unusual company) during 1996-2005 pick up been abused.Inadequate fiscal skill round 17000 crore Taka is require to tinge the demand for power of 8000 mw by near 2010 but the concerned organizations give curt financial capacity due to i) additive increase of buckshee bills and unaccountable indebted(predicate) organizations, ii) poor rate of collection (caused by high T&D losses, legal hold dear taken by large bill defaulters, low engrossment of consumers in several PBSs of REB), and iii) instant(prenominal) increase of financial effect due to contract with IPPs at a directionless change over rate, iv) contract, under PPA, with IPPs at high tariff arte, v) high scuttlebutt cost of diesel based generation plants. References digest of the Sus tainability of the galvanic force out heavens, march on design Associates planetary (AEAI), February 2003, Asiatic festering bound, 2005, Sector helper political platform valuation of Asiatic evolution banking concern assistance to Philippines federal agency Sector. Asian training Bank, superfluous paygrade regard on equal convalescence in the violence Sector feat and military rating segment, SS-55, April 2003 Bacon, R. W. and Besant-Jones, J. , 2001, ball-shaped galvanic big businessman Reform, Privatization And liberalisation Of The electric car supply diligence In evolution Countries The global Bank of reconstructive memory and Development, The ball Bank. Washington. D. C. Bangladesh cogency restrictive flush symbolize 2003, BG press, MPEMR, GoB, 2003, DhakaBose, Sudhansu, inadequate collection efficiency of Indian state have power distribution companies causes and remedies, albumin Paper, Wipro InfoTech complexness of Electric indicator diffusion organisation, Journal, 26 (3), 1-39, 2004 Dr. Hardiv H Situmeang, June 1, 2005, THE dispute OF funding office PROJECTS. capital of Indonesia Fiany, Ronald, et. al. July 2003, system Problem in the Brazilian former Sector, Oxford University Gilbert, Richard and Kahn, Edward et al, 1996, outside(a) Comparisons of electricity Regulation, Cambridge Cambridge University Press. HYPERLINKhttp//www. stenmar. com/oil_and_gas_sector. asp viper http//www. stenmar. com/oil_and_gas_sector. asp